Jeni's Watermelon Taffy Ice Cream

Meant to taste like a watermelon sour candy, this one’s for tart people, like Jeni. It’s got perfect, puckery fruit flavor from a little watermelon and plenty of citric acid, just like the candy.

The bouncier than a bouncy house character comes from fresh cultured buttermilk and yogurt (made just for us by a fifth generation Ohio dairy)—so every bite is both ethereally light and extraordinarily creamy. Great on its own, but makes for a great float with a crisp bubbly soda!